Fault proneness of ann under dempstershafer evidence theory and trimmedwinsorized means. The level of support for a hypothesis that is provided by the evidence is expressed as a numerical value per dempstershafer theory, implemented using the python programming language we calculate the belief and plausibility of a hypothesis. Section 4 provides a resume of some elementary facts of group and semigroup theory. Assigning confidence degrees masses to sets of alternatives mtrue 0. Dempstershafer theory dst, also known as the theory of evidence or the theory of belief functions, was introduced by shafer in 1976 1, based on dempsters previous works 24. The application of dempstershafer theory demonstrated. The paper presents an algorithm for translating the subontologies containing con. Combination of evidence in dempster shafer theory sandia. In ds theory, the degree of belief in evidence is analogous to the mass of a physical object mass of evidence supports a belief.
In this context the dempster shafer theory of evidence dst has shown some promising results. Dempstershafer theory for combining in silico evidence and. Different theories have been proposed in multisource data fusion, such as the bayesian approach, dempstershafer evidence theory dset 6. Data classification using the dempstershafer method arxiv. This paper presents a new classifier combination technique based on the dempster shafer theory of evidence.
On the behavior of dempsters rule of combination and the. Transportation of dangerous goods dgs is generally associated with significant levels of risk. Dempster with extensions by glen shafer in 1987 shafer, 1976. Dempstershafer theory application to clustering mass function belief and plausibility functions connection with rough sets interpretation. The degrees of belief of propositions are given by probabilities or beliefs. A simple view of the dempster shafer theory of evidence and its implication for the rule of combination lotfi a.
Bayesian and dempstershafer reasoning for knowledgebased. Bell school of electronics, electrical engineering and computer science queens university belfast belfast bt7 1nn, uk fj. Its capability to assign uncertainty or ignorance to propositions is a powerful tool for dealing with a large range of problems that otherwise would seem intractable. Dempstershafer theory for combining in silico evidence. A simple view of the dempstershafer theory of evidence and. A python library for performing calculations in the dempster shafer theory of evidence. The dempster shafer ds theory of evidence generalizes bayesian probability theory, by providing a coherent representation for ignorance lack of evidence. The dempstershafer theory, also known as the theory of belief functions, is a. Particularly appealing is the mathematical theory of evidence developed by arthur dempster. Here, an alternative theory of uncertainty is used, the dempstershafer theory of evidence sha76, because it is more flexible in modelling the ir. Dempstershafer theory offers an alternative to traditional probabilistic theory for the mathematical representation of uncertainty. If an agent obtains a new piece a of evidence, he may update his belief with the. This theory is being released because of following reason. However, uncertain relationships between evidence and hypotheses bearing on this evidence are difficult to represent in applications of the theory.
Application of extended dempstershafer theory of evidence in. Exploring the combination of dempstershafer theory and. Note, there is no pior data here, just numbers from human experts. Dempster shafer theory offers an alternative to traditional probabilistic theory for the mathematical representation of uncertainty. Application of extended dempstershafer theory of evidence. Apr 01, 2002 dempster shafer theory offers an alternative to traditional probabilistic theory for the mathematical representation of uncertainty. Dempstershafer theory dst, also known as the theory of evidence or the theory of belief functions, was introduced by shafer in 1976 1 based on dempsters previous works 2, 3, 4. Compared with bayesian theory, the dempstershafer theory of evidence feels closer to our human perception and reasoning processes. Time series dempstershafer evidence theory trimmedwinsorized means power unit prices 20. A wellknown theory of uncertainty used in ir is probability theory see fuh92 for a survey of probabilistic ir models. Combining classifiers using the dempster shafer theory of. Dempstershafer theory dst is a rigorous decisiontheory approach that provides a way to generate predictions, estimate the uncertainty associated with each prediction, and combine multiple sources of evidence to obtain a weightofevidence prediction by quantitatively accounting for the reliability of each of the sources being combined. Central to dempstershafer theory is the rule of combination of beliefs. As a more flexible mathematical tool, dempstershafer theory not only combines with other mathematical frameworks 1518, but also combines with.
In dempstershafer theory, it is this probability mass that is the focus, and it is the probability mass that constitutes the evidence. A library written in java for performing calculations in the dempstershafer theory of evidence. Using the dempstershafer theory of evidence to resolve. June 7, 2016 abstract the book that launched the dempster shafer theory of belief functions appeared 40 years ago. A simple view of the dempstershafer theory of evidence. The dempster shafer theory is a mathematical theory of evidence, which allows one to combine evidences from different sources and arrive at a belief function by taking into account all the available evidences. The application of dempstershafer theory demonstrated with justi. Dempstershafer theory of evidence2 dempstershafertheorydstheoryisderivedfromdempstersoriginalwork23,24that. Dempstershafer theory introduction, connections with rough. It has since been extended by numerous authors and popularised, but only to a degree, in the literature on artificial intelligence ai and expert systems, as a technique for modelling reasoning under. The significant innovation of this framework is that it allows. The dempstershafer theory of evidence jean gordon and edward h. Indeed, probability theory may be seen as a limit of dempstershafer evidence theory when it is assumed.
June 7, 2016 abstract the book that launched the dempstershafer theory of belief functions appeared 40 years ago. The dempster shafer theory is a mathematical theory of evidence based on belief functions and plausible reasoning, which is used to combine separate pieces of information evidence to calculate the probability of an event. This report surveys a number of possible combination rules for dempstershafer structures and provides examples of the implementation of these rules for discrete and intervalvalued data. Pdf combination of evidence in dempstershafer theory. For example, the widely used example in dempster shafer evidence theory is doctor dignosis, which doctor believe 60% the patient has disease a and 40% disease b. A mathematical theory of evidence turns 40 glenn shafer. Dempster shafer executes as a main fusion node, with the role to collect and fuse the information provided by the monitors, taking the final decision regarding a possible attack. This paper reports on a largescale experiment for the evaluation of a formal querybiased combination of evidence mechanism. In a narrow sense, the term dempstershafer theory refers to the original conception of the theory by dempster and shafer. It is much newer theory, originating in the work of a. An introduction liping liu college of business administration, university of akron, akron, oh 443254801 the notion of belief functions is a result of the seminar work of shafer1 and its conceptual forerunnerlower and upper probabilities. The dempstershafer theory of evidence is a powerful method for combining measures of evidence from different classifiers. Dempster shafer theory dst is a rigorous decision theory approach that provides a way to generate predictions, estimate the uncertainty associated with each prediction, and combine multiple sources of evidence to obtain a weight of evidence prediction by quantitatively accounting for the reliability of each of the sources being combined.
Combining multiple query interface matchers using dempstershafer theory of evidence jun hong, zhongtian he and david a. Section 5 investigates the semigroup structure of dempstershafer and states the main results relating it to bayes. The foundations of ds have been laid out by dempster 24, 6 and shafer 18 22. An introduction liping liu college of business administration, university of akron, akron, oh 443254801 the notion of belief functions is a result of the seminar work of shafer1 and its conceptual. After combining the evidence, a threshold of guilt can be established based on belief, such as 0.
The dempstershafer ds theory of evidence generalizes bayesian probability theory, by providing a coherent representation for ignorance lack of evidence. Bayesian theory is only concerned about single evidences. This report surveys a number of possible combination rules for dempster shafer structures and provides examples of the implementation of these rules for discrete and intervalvalued data. Shafer, 1976 is one of the main points of criticism this formalism has to face.
In your case, it may be better to use bayesian approch instead of dempster shafer evidence theory. Support for normalized as well as unnormalized belief functions different montecarlo algorithms for combining belief functions various methods related to the generalized bayesian theorem measures of uncertainty methods for constructing belief functions from data both python 2. The dempster shafer theory of evidence jean gordon and edward h. A python library for performing calculations in the dempstershafer theory of evidence. We use the dempstershafer theory of evidence to combine optimally results obtained by content and link analyses on the web.
Compared with bayesian theory, the dempster shafer theory of evidence feels closer to our human perception and reasoning processes. Dempster in 1967 and his student glenn shafer in 1976. Combining evidence in the extended dempstershafer theory. Different than the bayes rule, dempstershafer theory represents evidence as possibilistic belief. A new technique for combining multiple classifiers using. In the context of dg transportation, risk refers to the likelihood of incurring the undesirable consequences of a possible accident. This theory may be considered as a generalization of the probability theory. Dempstershafer theory introduction, connections with. When occurring or emerging it will support a set of propositions. In particular, it provides explicit estimations of imprecision and con. Dempster in the context of statistical inference, the theory was later developed by glenn. It sho wn that application of the dempstershafer rule com bination in this case leads to ev. Safety case confidence propagation based on dempstershafer.
Zadeh compufer science division, universify of california, berkeley, california 94720 the emergence of expert systems as one of the major ar. An introduction to bayesian and dempstershafer data fusion. Application of dempstershafer theory to the in silico prediction of chemical toxicity based on qsar models and rulebased structural alerts demonstrates the advantages of this approach. The dempstershafer theory dst of evidence originated in the work of dempster on the theory of probabilities with upper and lower bounds. Section 5 investigates the semigroup structure of dempster shafer and states the main results relating it to bayes. The theory allows one to combine evidence from different sources and arrive at a degree of belief represented by a mathematical object called belief function that takes into account all the available evidence. I came across the dempstershafer theory of evidence. The theory of belief functions, also referred to as evidence theory or dempstershafer theory dst, is a general framework for reasoning with uncertainty, with understood connections to other frameworks such as probability, possibility and imprecise probability theories. Distributed attack prevention using dempstershafer theory. The application of dempstershafer theory demonstrated with. Dempstershafer theory does not require an assumption regarding the probability of the individual constituents of the set or interval. Bayes theory is based on the classical ideas of probability, while dempstershafer theory is a recent attempt to allow more interpretation of what uncertainty is all about.
An alternative to the bayesian theory of evidence is dempstershafer theory which produces results similar to bayesian theory. Novel paradigm for constructing masses in dempstershafer. May 10, 2017 transportation of dangerous goods dgs is generally associated with significant levels of risk. The dempstershafer theory of evidence is a formalism, which allows appropriate interpretation of extractors con. Ds is a mathematical theory of evidence based on belief functions and plausible reasoning. Situations and evidence for identity using dempstershafer theory. The dempster shafer theory of evidence is a powerful method for combining measures of evidence from different classifiers. The theory of belief functions, also referred to as evidence theory or dempster shafer theory dst, is a general framework for reasoning with uncertainty, with. The dempstershafer theory is a mathematical theory of evidence, which allows one to combine evidences from different sources and arrive at a belief function by taking into account all the available evidences. A new technique for combining multiple classifiers using the. The dempstershafer theory dst is a mathematical theory of evidence. Support for normalized as well as unnormalized belief functions different montecarlo algorithms for combining belief functions various methods related to the generalized bayesian theorem measures of uncertainty methods for constructing belief. The significant innovation of this framework is that it allows for the allocation of a probability mass to sets or intervals.
Dempster shafer theory application to clustering mass function belief and plausibility functions connection with rough sets interpretation. This intellectual autobiography looks back on how i came to write the book and how its ideas played out in my later work. A simple view of the dempstershafer theory of evidence and its implication for the rule of combination lotfi a. Towards argumentation with symbolic dempstershafer. Distributed attack prevention using dempstershafer theory of. Forecasting errors for ann under dempstershafer evidence theory and trimmedwinsorized means. Special issue on the dempstershafer theory of evidence. An important aspect of this theory is the combination of evidence obtained from multiple sources and the modeling of conflict between them. The goal of the combination of imperfect information is to nd an accurate information, easily interpretable, which can resume the information set to be combined. Time series forecasting using artificial neural networks. A case of combination of evidence in the dempstershafer.
Dempster shafer theory does not require an assumption regarding the probability of the individual constituents of the set or interval. Shortliffe the drawbacks of pure probabilistic methods and of the certainty factor model have led us in recent years to consider alternate approaches. An important aspect of this theory is the combination of evidence obtained from multiple sources and the modeling of conflict. In this report we will discuss the above two philosophies or paradigms that make up. Dempstershafers theory of evidence applied to structured. The theory of belief functions, also referred to as evidence theory or dempstershafer theory dst, is a general framework for reasoning with uncertainty, with. Dempster shafer theory and statistical inference with weak. Approximations for decision making in the dempstershafer. This paper presents a new classifier combination technique based on the dempstershafer theory of evidence.
Where to get a good understanding of dempstershafer theory of. Combining multiple query interface matchers using dempster. Using the dempstershafer theory of evidence to resolve abox. In this work we have proposed three novel algorithms to combine different biometric systems using the dst. Zadeh compufer science division, universify of california, berkeley, california 94720 the emergence of expert systems as one of the major ar eas of activity within ai has resulted in a rapid growth of. Scalable clustering using the dempstershafer theory of. This theory offers an elegant theoretical framework for modeling uncertainty, and provides a method for combining distinct bodies of evidence collected from. Combination of evidence in dempstershafer theory unt. Since the probability of an accident in a link of a route might depend on a variety of factors, it is necessary to find a way to combine the pieces of evidence. Dst is an evidence theory, it combines all possible outcomes of the problem.
Jeffreylike rules of conditioning for the dempstershafer theory of. I suggest you to see links and attached files on topic. Fundamental difference between ds theory and probability theory is the treatment of ignorance. Expert systemsdempstershafer theory wikibooks, open books. The dempstershafer theory is both a successor of fishers. This theory offers an elegant theoretical framework for modeling uncertainty, and provides a method for combining distinct bodies of evidence collected.
616 1425 1261 982 319 986 1261 1594 1392 955 1124 1602 1309 333 1557 1240 1052 1214 458 1481 10 326 1143 690 400 1168 1048 785 184 1329 908